Path: vixen.cso.uiuc.edu!newsfeed.internetmci.com!uunet!bounce-back From: Jani Patokallio Newsgroups: news.announce.newgroups,news.groups,alt.philosophy.objectivism Subject: RESULT: humanities.philosophy.objectivism moderated passes 362:46 Supersedes: <832200161.21583@uunet.uu.net> Followup-To: news.groups Date: 6 Jun 1996 12:06:20 -0400 Organization: Usenet Volunteer Votetakers Lines: 590 Sender: tale@uunet.uu.net Approved: newgroups-request@uunet.uu.net Message-ID: <834077018.29083@uunet.uu.net> Reply-To: voting@hut.fi NNTP-Posting-Host: rodan.uu.net Archive-Name: humanities.philosophy.objectivism Xref: vixen.cso.uiuc.edu news.announce.newgroups:8483 news.groups:197887 alt.philosophy.objectivism:120321 RESULT moderated group humanities.philosophy.objectivism passes 362:46 There were 362 YES votes and 46 NO votes, for a total of 408 valid votes. There was 1 abstain and 1 invalid ballot. For group passage, YES votes must be at least 2/3 of all valid (YES and NO) votes. There also must be at least 100 more YES votes than NO votes. There is a five day discussion period after these results are posted. If no serious allegations of voting irregularities are raised, the moderator of news.announce.newgroups will create the group shortly thereafter. Newsgroups line: humanities.philosophy.objectivism The ideas of Ayn Rand. (Moderated) The voting period closed at 23:59:59 UTC, 5 Jun 1996. This vote was conducted by a neutral third party. Questions about the proposed group should be directed to the proponent. Proponent: Jason Kuznicki Votetaker: Jani Patokallio VOTETAKER'S NOTE: Despite heated discussion and accusations of fraud by both sides, there was no evidence of any fraud in the voting itself that I could see. Both sides overdid their campaigning, but the result was remarkably unanimous and remains so even if the few mildly suspicious (ie. not a direct reply to the CFV) votes are eliminated. As it is, only the obvious (accidental) duplicate votes were removed as usual. RATIONALE: humanities.philosophy.objectivism Alt.philosophy.objectivism (a.p.o.), a currently existing group for the discussion of the philosophy created by Ayn Rand and known as Objectivism, has become nearly useless as a forum for discussion of philosophy because of extremely high traffic of irrelevant crossposts, spaming and flaming. Though they have been repeatedly asked to leave, the perpetrators of these abuses continue to disturb a.p.o. The problems of a.p.o. are particularly great because Objectivism is in many respects an unconventional philosophy and thus tends to attract posters who are extremely hostile to it, including trolls and the perpetrators of interminable flamewars. These problems can be avoided by those interested in Objectivism through the creation of a moderated newsgroup. Traffic on h.p.o. will be significant; previous proposals and the first RFD were met with numerous e-mail and posted messages by individuals who plan to post to the group regularly. The proposal should in no way be considered an attempt to moderate or replace a.p.o., whose status will not change with the creation of h.p.o. The newsgroup's name follows established protocol with regard to newsgroup creation. Objectivism is a philosophy; philosophy is a part of the studies commonly called the humanities. Finally, the humanities.* hierarchy is a legitimate and previously recognized first-level hierarchy. CHARTER: humanities.philosophy.objectivism Humanities.philosophy.objectivism shall exist for the purpose of fur- thering discussion by Objectivists and those who admire Ayn Rand's ideas. Those who disagree with these ideas may of course also post to h.p.o. for the purposes of civilized debate and discussion of Object- ivism. Any posters who persistently abuse their posting privileges are subject to revocation of these privileges at the discretion of the moderator (qv). Discussion on h.p.o. may consist of attempts to support, elaborate, apply, question, or refute the tenets of Objectivist philosophy on the part of participants. For example, discussion on h.p.o. may include but is in no way limited to the topics of Anarchism in relation to Objectivism and the dispute between David Kelley and Leonard Peikoff as it relates to Objectivist philosophy. Posts which request general information about a particular topic of Objectivist philosophy or on the availability of resources related to Objectivism are also welcome. Every effort shall be made by the posters of h.p.o. to compile a thor- ough text-only FAQ describing the moderation and posting policies of h.p.o. Crossposting shall not be permitted, excepting administrative posts such as further RFDs, CFVs, and the FAQ. With the approval of the administrator such material may be crossposted to news.announce.new- groups, news.answers, news.groups, and other groups deemed necessary by the moderator. Because a philosophy such as Objectivism has ap- plications in numerous areas of human action, the actors in many of which are not themselves directly concerned with Objectivism, discus- sions that are crossposted often become irrelevant to one or the other of the groups. This has been a major problem with a.p.o. in the past. Moderation Policy: The newsgroup shall be automoderated; the automoderator shall be overseen by a nonparticipant net administrator. The automoderator shall automatically reject all articles that fall into the following categories: A) Articles that contain more than 80 characters per line; B) Articles that are crossposted; C) Encoded binary messages; D) Messages containing more than 20 lines of text, 80% or more of which is quoted material; E) Articles authored by those that the moderator has expelled from the group (see below). The submitters of rejected articles shall be sent a copy of the FAQ to inform them of the reason why their submissions were rejected. The moderator of h.p.o. shall be Tim Skirvin . The alternate moderator of h.p.o. shall be Richard E. Depew . The moderators shall not post to humanities.philosophy.objectivism except as administrative duties require. Commercial postings shall not be permitted; repeated posting of a commercial nature shall be grounds for the banning of the submitter from humanities.philosophy.objectivism at the discretion of the mod- erator. The moderator is further authorized to cancel said postings if and when they appear, forwarding a copy of the FAQ to the poster. If a FAQ is not yet available, a copy of this charter shall be sent instead. Postings commonly acknowledged by the Usenet community to be "spam" or similar forms of net-abuse shall not be permitted; the moderator is authorized to cancel all such posts, inform the submitter of his decision, and, if the abuse persists after an initial warning, ban the submitter of the posts from the newsgroup. The moderator may also cancel posts which are offtopic for the group. For example, humanities.philosophy.objectivism excludes the discus- sion of Neo-Tech, Zon Power and the publications and activities of the Neo-Tech Publishing Company. Such material is off-topic for humanities.philosophy.objectivism and repeated posts of this nature shall result in the expulsion of the poster. The Automoderator may also be programmed and reprogrammed as necessary to return the ex- cluded postings to the sender, attatching a copy of the FAQ for h.p.o. No specific individuals shall be excluded from h.p.o., save as their behavior on the forum itself warrants. The alternate shall succeed the moderator upon retirement. Should the alternate be unwilling to do so, the moderator may choose an- other impartial nonparticipant individual to fill his place. END CHARTER. MODERATOR INFO: humanities.philosophy.objectivism Moderator: tskirvin@uiuc.edu (Tim Skirvin) Article submission address: tskirvin+hpo@math.uiuc.edu Administrative contact address: tskirvin@uiuc.edu END MODERATOR INFO. humanities.philosophy.objectivism Final Vote Ack Voted Yes ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 0005791716@mcimail.com Rodney Schroeter 0006309785@mcimail.com Evan Picoult 100024.2311@CompuServe.COM Alex LEIBOVICI 100275.3045@CompuServe.COM Victor Manta 73261.1750@CompuServe.COM Darlene Price 73742.1572@CompuServe.COM Greg Greenberg 74734.2473@CompuServe.COM Darius Cooper 75613.2610@CompuServe.COM Tedd Potts aarond@ewl.uky.edu Aaron B. Dossett adam@visalia.com Adam Wildavsky afargnol@spdmail.spd.dsccc.com Al Fargnoli aj@wimsey.com Aristotle Jones ajohnson@netexpress.net Aaron Johnson. alann@primenet.com Alan Nitikman alattin@postbox.acs.ohio-state.edu Alex Lattin albertc1@ix.netcom.com Albert Carrasco allenjk@frontiernet.net Jay Allen aloomis@whale.st.usm.edu Austin George Loomis ananjan@seas.ucla.edu Sanjiv Dhir andrewl@microsoft.com Andrew Layman andy@pagan.net Winston Andy Collier andyl@harlequin.com Andy Latto apollo@ns.bitstream.net Chuck Freeman archer@hsc.fr Vincent Archer arielle@taronga.com Stephanie da Silva arromdee@hops.cs.jhu.edu Ken Arromdee ASBAB@acad2.alaska.edu BARBARA A BAUM asdalton@umich.edu Andrew Seth Dalton ashipley@hookup.net Ayn Shipley audi-vw@ix.netcom.com Lee Behel aw486@freenet.carleton.ca John Monroe awc112@psu.edu Alexander Cadman bah161@hbc.psu.edu Brett Hoffstadt bai@msiadmin.cit.cornell.edu Dov Bai-MSI Visitor baisa@hookup.net Brad Aisa bart+@CMU.EDU Bartosz Blacha bazyar@hypermall.com Jawaid Bazyar bbrown@asu.edu Bill Brown Benderjg@aol.com James G. Bender benzeev@inow.com Freddy Ben-Zeev berger@primenet.com George Berger bethcar@microsoft.com Beth Carter betsy@speicher.com Betsy Speicher birchall@email.njin.net Shag black123@apci.net Tom Blackburn blairs@sprynet.com Blair Schofield bmau@austin.geoquest.slb.com Bryan Mau bney@austin.geoquest.slb.com Bill Ney bnicoll@cloud9.net Bruce Nicoll Broad1@aol.com Victoria Trask bruce@aracnet.com Bruce Baugh bumgarls@jmu.edu Lee S. Bumgarner bweck@eng.ua.edu Barry Weck bwill@teleport.com Brad Williams byoder@netcom.com Brian K. Yoder b_young@cc.colorado.edu Brook Young ca276@freenet.toronto.on.ca Kristen Plummer catseye@netcom.com Mark Kupferman cervante@gate.net Mike Cervantes chaotic@u.washington.edu Lorraine McConaghy chouston@austin.geoquest.slb.com Chad Houston chris@kai.com Chris Huson chrisland@ghgcorp.com Christopher K. Land churchh@uts.cc.utexas.edu Henry Churchyard cjsandvi@apollo1.uophx.edu Chris Sandvick CMisciagno@aol.com Craig Misciagno. cosh@freenet.edmonton.ab.ca cox@climate.asrc.albany.edu Steve Cox cretsi@d0sgi0.fnal.gov Cathy Cretsinger crucial@ix.netcom.com Brad Wilson/Crucial Software cs922018@red.ariel.cs.yorku.ca DINO CARUBIA cshelton@austin.geoquest.slb.com Charlie Shelton cwalker@ece.utexas.edu Chris Walker dana@bigdog.chem.ucla.edu Dana Elese Holmes daniel@vis.inf.ethz.ch Daniel Gerald Kluge danw@postoffice.ttmc.com Dan Wisehart DASHIELL@VTVM1.CC.VT.EDU Shoshana Milgram Knapp Dave@Weston-CDP.Com Dave Weston, CDP davidsch@microsoft.com David Schach david_kloba@il.us.swissbank.com David Kloba dc6f+@andrew.cmu.edu Douglas B Clayton dc@panix.com Minister of Truth decicco@village.ios.com Grace De Cicco deep@endure.demon.co.uk Richard Brooke devans@hclb.demon.co.uk Dave Evans dgarcia@globalreach.com Domingo Garcia dhankins@gate.net Daniel B. Hankins diana@artsci.wustl.edu D.M. Brickell dixon@merlot.Stanford.EDU Bill Dixon DKnightDLK@aol.com Duane L. Knight DMCKAMEY@UWYO.EDU Daryl McKamey dmullen@austin.geoquest.slb.com Dawn Mullen dputzolu@teleport.com David M. Putzolu drafner@capitalism.com David Rafner dred@ix.netcom.com Jeremy Dombroski DRUSAN@ix.netcom.com Daniel Rusanowsky dshaw@cs.jhu.edu David Shaw dws@ora.com DaviD W. Sanderson eae@tripnet.se Erik Emilson eirich@quark.arl.psu.edu Peter Eirich EJB1@trpo3.tr.unisys.com Eric J. Barinka ejohnson@netcom.com Eric Johnson ekraft@netcom.com Erik Kraft eli@wwa.com Eli Lehrer endgame@cris.com Jason Kuznicki ericvas@microsoft.com Kenneth Eric Vasilik erik@hypermall.com Erik Kloeppel ewm@gladstone.uoregon.edu Ed Matthews fa2ramon@usc.es Jose Ramon Flores Seijas FAHRNER@VM.CC.PURDUE.EDU David Fahrner fiester@community.net Paul Fiester flick@ritz.mordor.com Dale Flick foosi@global.california.com Michael R. Brown frankman@microsoft.com Frank Mantek frisco@grove.ufl.EDU Cameron Michelis fseiler@netaxs.com Frederick Seiler gabes@ix.netcom.com Gabriel R. Stern garcia@phys.psu.edu Rafael Garcia garyt@hpdmlfn.boi.hp.com Gary Thomas george.barota@jonkoping.mail.telia.com George Barota george@admin.dce.utah.edu George Plautz gep@micron.net Greg Perkins gglynn@hookup.net Gerry Glynn gideons@microsoft.com Gideon Schaller GLF3@PSUVM.PSU.EDU Greg Fisher gmidonne@email.gc.cuny.edu gilbert midonnet gmorrone@prolog.net George Morrone GOTTHELF@TSCVM.TRENTON.EDU Allan Gotthelf greich@primenet.com Gideon Reich griggs@warp.msoe.edu Ed Griggs Gsarup@aol.com Gautam Sarup gt1491a@prism.gatech.edu Josh LeVasseur gt2623a@prism.gatech.edu Timothy Ronald Volk gt5929b@prism.gatech.edu Scott Lange gt6234b@prism.gatech.edu Joshua Bardwell gyst@cd.chalmers.se Peter Gustafson haber001@gold.tc.umn.edu Jeffrey M Haber hayosh@ukraine.corp.mot.com Tom Hayosh hcl@oden.se H.C.LEGERHEIM hdg101@psu.edu Hans D. Gougar Henrik.Anderson@tripnet.se Henrik Anderson hmullin@ix.netcom.com Harry Mullin hsiehp@crl.com Paul S. Hsieh (e-mail: > HSOLO6472@aol.com Henry Solomon ibmstuff@oknet.com David PC Wollmann ijackson@chiark.chu.cam.ac.uk Ian Jackson irilyth@infersys.com Josh Smith istvanc@microsoft.com Istvan Cseri jadams@pe-netsystems.com Jon Adams jalway@ICSI.Net John Alway jason_beaver@il.us.swissbank.com Jason Beaver JayBatman@aol.com Jay Batman jazz@mail.netime.com Jasmine St. John jberls@cris.com Jodi Berls jbf0@gte.com Jeff "Spike" Flaster JBSing123@aol.com Joseph Singer jdousey@voicenet.com James D Ousey Jeanemarie@aol.com Jean Perry jed@poisson.com Jason Durbin jelder@netexpress.net John Elder Jenniffer_Woodson@ACADEMIC-AFFAIRS.ucsd.edu Jenniffer Woodson Jens.Norrgrann@abc.se Jens Norrgrann jens@mailbox.calypso.net Jens Larsson jggoslin@Oakland.edu Jeff Goslin jhester@austin.geoquest.slb.com John Hester jimmy@walrus.com Jimmy Pena jkoontz@erols.com James H. Koontz jle@mo.net James L. Elswick JMAflower@aol.com JMAflower jmedwid@gpu.srv.ualberta.ca Jason Medwid jmerrick@netcom.com Jeffrey D. Merrick jngodin@vaxxine.com J. G. jo1t+@andrew.cmu.edu Jon David Orris joakimh@tripnet.se Joakim Hasselblad John_Yokela@adoc.xerox.com John Yokela jon@netdepot.com Jon Gordon Jon_Jurik/CRC.CRC@nmail.crcnyc.com Jon Jurik/CRC JP@hep.anl.gov John Power jpc@hammer.msfc.nasa.gov J. Porter Clark JPinker126@aol.com Jayson M Pinkerman jpm@athens.engr.sgi.com John McCaskey jrodda@chem.ucla.edu Jonathan Rodda jrs@poe.acc.virginia.edu Boris Starosta jrtallen@MailBox.Syr.Edu Jack Tallent jswot@cyberstore.ca JTaub82748@aol.com Jay Taub judys@goodnet.com Judy Sawyer justiniano@mdn.net Kendall Justiniano jwales@mars.mcs.com Jimmy Wales jwbales@auburn.campus.mci.net John W. Bales jwheeler@austin.geoquest.slb.com Joanne Wheeler kalafut@emunix.emich.edu Gerald Allen Kalafut kamins@tlg.net Scot Kamins kate@rigel.econ.uga.edu Kate Wrightson keg0072@aol.com Barbara Chisholm khaight@netcom.com Kyle Haight kim@shell.portal.com Kim DeVaughn kirshenbaum@hplms26.hpl.hp.com Evan Kirshenbaum klos@Oakland.edu klos kmajor@public.srce.hr Kazimir Majorinc kmyeager@aristotle.csd.sgi.com Kurt Yeager kraucunas_nina@po.gis.prc.com Kraucunas Nina KriegerMS@aol.com John Krieger krsweidy@ix.netcom.com Kimberly R. Sweidy L5H280@fek.su.se Tobias Eriksson ladd@yield.ENET.dec.com Anne Moroney Ladd x6303 HLO2-3/L12,N10 8CMOSLD 20- lajosf@microsoft.com Lajos Frank larry@bayes.wustl.edu Larry Bretthorst, Ph.D. laszlog@microsoft.com Laszlo Gaal lcs@zk3.dec.com Larry Smith leary@accessone.com Michael Leary lgriffith@qnet.com Lionell Griffith liberty@eskimo.com Michael A. Justice LindaMann@msn.com Linda Mann linden@ilink.net Linden Doerr lkh@pobox.com Lisa K. Holsberg lmdasilv@acs.ucalgary.ca Lina Da Silva lsanger@magnus.acs.ohio-state.edu Lawrence M. Sanger lyceum@tripnet.se Jerry Nilson macf@munin.dc.hks.se Christian Wernstedt madison@nsu.acast.nova.edu Peggy Madison MADMAX888@aol.com Art Furtzaig Magnus.Kempe@di.epfl.ch Magnus Kempe marcellus@medcor.mcgill.ca Richard Marcellus Mark.A.Peters@cdc.com Mark A. Peters marklin@flash.net George Marklin marksj@magellan.Colorado.EDU James Marks martin@plaza.ds.adp.com Martin Golding MARTIND@TEN-NASH.TEN.K12.TN.US Glenn Martin matitko@MIT.EDU Michael Titko mattz@tsoft.net Matt Zwolinski mb@agar.oche.de Marcus Breiing MBWallace@aol.com Mark B. Wallace MCenedella@aol.com Marc Cenedella mcna0070@itlabs.umn.edu RONALD S MCNABB mein@u.washington.edu A. Mein mescanne@undergrad.math.uwaterloo.ca Mark Scannell mgillman@halcyon.com Michael Gillman Michael_Hutchins@qmlink.draper.com P. Michael Hutchins Mishnah@aol.com Brian Lounsberry mjg@oms.com Mark J. Gardner moz19@allinux1.alliance.net John Mozena mpeter@primenet.com Mark A. Peter mrc@xdiv.lanl.gov Mike Clover msandber@Sigma4.com Martin Sandberg mstaple@insync.net Mark Stapleton mtj@iglou.com Michael Jones mtkinney@MailBox.Syr.Edu Matthew T. Kinney nberls@austin.geoquest.slb.com Norman J. Berls norm@mtgbcs.mt.att.com Norman E. Andrews npandya@ea.oac.uci.edu Nitin Pandya nrich@ss-n.com Nicholas Rich nw527@brainiac.com Harris Kenner oghate@acs.ucalgary.ca Onkar Ghate Olaf.Weber@cwi.nl Olaf Weber oraq@cs.utexas.edu Eric Hollas p.voss@ix.netcom.com Peter Voss pankaj@uic.edu Pankaj Saxena paris@byu.edu Robert Craig Harman paul@vix.com Paul A Vixie pcj@io.org Peter Johnson pduncan@iaw.on.ca Paul Duncan pem4@psu.edu Paul Moser peter@taronga.com Peter da Silva phil2@iquest.net Philip Oliver phillips@bright.uoregon.edu Chris Phillips pmmjr@crosslink.net Phil Mc prime@winternet.com Chuck Prime psg95jc@prism.gatech.edu John S. Cobb pulchra@prairienet.org Chris Gurney r2bkm@VM1.CC.UAKRON.EDU Belete Muturo rage@st.rim.or.jp Matt Merges RandyGrow@aol.com Randy Grow raymie@larch.lcs.mit.edu Raymie Stata rcarrier@suba.com Ronald M. Carrier rcunni@osprey.unf.edu Richard Cunningham rds@astral.magic.ca Robert D. Stevens RDWoehl@aol.com Roger Woehl reichln@ltec.net Gary Reichlinger rgood@qb.island.net Ron Good rick@bcm.tmc.edu Richard H. Miller rick@thunder-ink.com Rick VanNorman rick@tolive.vnet.net Rick Pasotto rickw@tripnet.se Rikard Wollin rkagan@ewald.mbi.ucla.edu Ron Kagan rminto@julian.uwo.ca Rick Minto rmockett@post.cis.smu.edu Robin Mockett robwoo19@skypoint.com Rob Wood roel.verbunt@tip.nl Roel Verbunt rohit@eci1.ucsb.edu Rohit Gupta ron@sj.unisys.com Ron Hickman roophy@asturnet.es Rudy Vonk rouss@netrospect.com Dan F. Rousseau RPDrake@aol.com Paul Drake rsc@advanced.org R. S. Camm rtarr@ibl.bm Rob Tarr RVernag@aol.com Ray Vernagus s940747@umslvma.umsl.edu Clay Matthew Hellman samu@uta.fi Samu Mielonen scardina@bcn.net Christopher Scardina scheeler@primenet.com Tom Scheeler scott.schad@wcom.com Scott T. Schad, scott.schad@wcom.com. SCrosby52@aol.com Scott Crosby scrutnzr@inforamp.net Jim May SDIXON@cccpp.com Stephanie Dixon SDRISCOLL@UBmail.ubalt.edu Sally Driscoll seans@sonic.net Sean Saulsbury sgedeon@interlog.com Dr. Steven A. Gedeon shoom@astral.magic.ca Greg Shoom simon.patkin@hkatl.com Simon Patkin simpson@math.psu.edu Stephen G. Simpson smurphy@chem.ucla.edu Sean Murphy sodapop+@CMU.EDU Daniel Morris DeRight speicher@cco.caltech.edu Stephen Speicher ST5F2@Jetson.UH.EDU Meredith L. Patterson steph@cyberenet.net steph stephen@srbailey.com Stephen A. Bailey Steve_Hoffmann@qmail4.nba.TRW.COM Steve Hoffmann steve_williams@ptltd.com steve_williams SUZPARKER@aol.com Suzanne Parker sven@mcs.net Sven Ericsson svengato@datasync.com Sven Redsun swih0001@gold.tc.umn.edu Jason Swihart tabitie@iastate.edu Shirley J. Keller tbaker@austin.geoquest.slb.com Terry Baker tdonadio@panix.com Tony Donadio ted_horst@il.us.swissbank.com Ted Horst tgriff@ix.netcom.com Tom Griffin thowe@io.org Todd Howe tlwright@umich.edu Tom Wright tmiovas@metronet.com Thomas M. Miovas, Jr. toby.white@university-college.oxford.ac.uk Toby White tom.rothacker@asu.edu Thomas M. Rothacker tomtapp@ee.gatech.edu Thomas L. Tapp Tony.Grundon@asu.edu Tony Grundon torrance@gpu.srv.ualberta.ca Kelly Torrance TPARSONS@library.iupui.edu Tym Parsons tpb@hpbs669.boi.hp.com Tim Blair trader@algonet.se Martin Lindeskog tskirvin@uiuc.edu Tim Skirvin tyler_gingrich@il.us.swissbank.com Tyler Gingrich vatcher@primenet.com Toni M. Vatcher VCCX79A@prodigy.com Steven J. Holmes velj@sn.no Vebjorn Ljosa VWFM54A@prodigy.com MR RAPHAEL RENTA w9sz@prairienet.org Zack Widup wallbrid@spots.ab.ca jim wallbridge walt@scott.net Walt Moffett webers@primenet.com Steven Weber westphal@theory.caltech.edu Eric Westphal whembree@Sigma4.com Bill Hembree wickre@cheddar.physics.wisc.edu Paul Wickre wiemann@lfs.loral.com King W. Wiemann willp@albany.net Will Pierce wjb3@mindspring.com Billy Beck wjc@essc.psu.edu Bill Capehart woo@seagull.rtd.com Jane Woo ws@xivic.ruhr.de Wolfgang Schelongowski wwfiv@nskernel.tandem.com William W. Farley IV yoichi@gol.com Yoichi Tamura yu121569@YorkU.CA Steve Smolinski ZMGM05A@prodigy.com Dennis Baldwin Voted No ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ afabbro@umich.edu Andrew Fabbro ALeftist@aol.com Jon Gray bbacon@cqi.com William H Bacon Jr booda@datasync.com Martin H. Booda bryce@digicash.com casar@uni-mb.si Ales Casar Caudillo42@aol.com Jose Fernandez cls48@columbia.edu Christopher Lodge Stamper csaamw@urc.tue.nl Michiel Wijers daniel.rybowski@infoboard.be Daniel Rybowski dbriblet@students.wisc.edu Doug Riblet dcell@cftnet.com Dave defy@teekay.win.net DEFanyo ericj@sundial.sundial.net Eric Juttelstad fishe@casbah.acns.nwu.edu Carwil James iordonez@magnus.acs.ohio-state.edu Ivan Ordonez jaed@best.com Jeanne A. E. DeVoto jbredeho@deltanet.com John E. Bredehoft jepresc@nextel.net James E. Prescott jimgm@netcom.com Jim Miller Jim_Mann@transarc.com Jim Mann john@handel.jlc.net John Leslie jonivar@th.ph.ed.ac.uk jon ivar skullerud jquinton@cs1.presby.edu Jeff Quinton jsreed@interaccess.com J. Stephen Reed Karl.Tombre@loria.fr Karl Tombre khan@cs.nyu.edu Hasnain Khan kwattles@sas.upenn.edu Kirk Wattles litlnemo@seanet.com Wendi Dunlap mac7@po.CWRU.Edu Mike Chary ml3e+@andrew.cmu.edu Michael Loomis neeri@iis.ee.ethz.ch Matthias Neeracher olav@viking.mv.com Olav Nieuwejaar Ollivier.Robert@hsc.fr Ollivier Robert patl@catfish.lcs.mit.edu Patrick J. LoPresti paxil@interlog.com Trevor Tymchuk rossix!davidmo@openlink.one-o.com David Moore shrao@nyx.net Shrisha Rao sledge@hammer.oche.de Thomas Bueschgens smith@ieng.washington.edu Robert P. Smith stainles@bga.com Dwight Brown tasquith@maildrop.srv.ualberta.ca Tom Asquith tlawson@email.univpubs.american.edu Todd C. Lawson tvc15@foo.garply.com T. Cabellero yorick@ic.net Steven E. Arlow zdlh19@sc.msc.edu David L. Hanson Abstained ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ mccomb@best.com Todd Michel McComb Votes in error ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ jmosby@micron.com John Mosby ! No vote statement in message -- Jani Patokallio Voting address: